The final moments of American Primeval see Isaac, Sarah, and Devin making their way to Crooks Springs. Upon reaching the creek, Isaac expresses his desire to remain in the wild, unwilling to accompany them into town.
Sarah, feeling heartbroken, urges him to part ways and allow her to proceed with Devin to meet his father, as she fears Devin’s father would disapprove of her connection with Isaac. After their emotional farewell, Devin suggests heading to California instead of visiting his father, but Sarah declines, citing concerns for his safety.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0729d/0729dbd809ebb6ec711217eeee5e9e756c30e9e7" alt=""
As the story comes to play, Sarah discovers a bundle of cash in her bag, only to be confronted by Lucas, who insists she join him on horseback. In a dramatic turn of events, Isaac intervenes just in time to disrupt their confrontation. A fierce struggle ensues, resulting in a tragic outcome for both Isaac and Lucas, leaving Sarah in profound distress.
Does Isaac Die in American Primeval?
Indeed, Isaac meets his end in American Primeval during Episode 6. Following a poignant goodbye with Sarah and Devin, he spots a doll belonging to the French family at the bounty hunters’ campsite. Recognizing the imminent threat to Sarah’s safety, he swiftly returns, only to find Lucas menacingly confronting her.
Isaac arrives just in time to fatally shoot Lucas. Unfortunately, he soon realizes he has been shot in the process. In a heartbreaking moment, he dies in Sarah’s arms, leaving her devastated. Following this tragedy, Sarah, Devin, and Two Moons hold a funeral to honor Isaac’s memory, marking the sorrowful conclusion of his story.