Reviewing a Knives Out film before its public release is tricky because the series thrives on surprise. Each installment mixes mystery and comedy with numerous twists, meaning even small plot details could spoil the experience. Previous films, like Knives Out and Glass Onion, revealed key elements—such as the main viewpoint character or the central murder—that would ruin the mystery if discussed too early.
The third installment, Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery, revolves around the puzzling death of Monsignor Jefferson Wicks, a hardline preacher at odds with Reverend Jud Duplenticy. Jud is suspected by Wicks’ devout congregation, yet he maintains his innocence and collaborates with detective Benoit Blanc. The investigation gradually uncovers layered secrets, inviting the audience to guess along with the characters.
Faith, Morality, and Complex Characters Drive a Modern Religious Mystery Narrative
Unlike previous films, which skewered the wealthy, this story delves into religion and morality. The conflict between Jud and Wicks highlights contrasting approaches to faith—Jud’s compassionate, if fiery, methods versus Wicks’ authoritarian style. Blanc, the perceptive outsider, adds nuance as a “heretic” ally, allowing the film to explore belief, truth, and storytelling in a thoughtful, progressive way that stands out in modern Christian-themed cinema.
Josh O’Connor as Jud Duplenticy (Wake Up Dead Man/T-Street Productions)While Jud and Wicks drive the narrative, the film features a diverse ensemble representing different facets of the religious right. Notable characters include influencer Cy Draven, his lawyer sister Vera, bitter Dr. Nat Sharp, faith-seeker Simone Vivane, and author Lee Ross. The cast’s performances are strong, though the story primarily spotlights the two Joshes—O’Connor and Brolin—alongside Daniel Craig’s Blanc, ensuring a clear focus amid the complexity.
Balancing Classic Mystery Homage with Sharp Contemporary Satire and Cultural Insight
Wake Up Dead Man honors classic mystery conventions, drawing inspiration from works like John Dickson Carr’s The Hollow Man. At the same time, it maintains a sharp contemporary edge, reflecting cultural sensibilities of 2025 despite being shot earlier. Rian Johnson’s signature balance of homage and modern satire keeps the series both timeless and relevant.
The film methodically develops its intricate plot, which can make the early acts feel long, but the final resolution delivers satisfying twists and thoughtful commentary on truth in a post-truth world. Audiences can expect humor, clever surprises, and subtle cultural insights. Wake Up Dead Man premiered at TIFF 2025, will release in theaters on November 26, and stream on Netflix on December 12.
