The first season of Matlock may have wrapped up, but it’s clear that the finale left plenty of unresolved threads that could have lasting impacts. The events leading up to this final episode were filled with tension as characters like Billy and Sarah confronted their complicated feelings, and Olympia faced her challenges with Matty.
Matty, on her part, also acknowledged her wrongdoings, giving her a significant moment to reflect. Many characters in Matlock were given their moment to shine, making the finale a crucial point in the story. Given the overwhelming praise the show has received.

It’s not surprising that the season finale is hailed as one of the most well-crafted episodes in recent television. By the end of the episode, most of the lingering questions have been addressed, though a few answers spark even more curiosity about the future.
This leaves viewers with an array of questions to ponder, but the finale does a great job of handling them with precision, keeping each issue distinct.
Cliffhangers That Will Shape Season 2
The season 1 finale of Matlock ended with four significant cliffhangers, all of which are bound to carry forward into the next season. Olympia uncovers that Julian was involved in the Wellbrexa cover-up, though she hasn’t yet decided how to handle this information.
Meanwhile, Billy discovers that Claudia is pregnant, and Alfie finds his long-lost father. On top of these revelations, Matty’s secret remains on the verge of being exposed. The moral support Olympia offers Matty could be tested in the next season, with her loyalty potentially torn between protecting a friend and her own family.
These intense moments come at a fast pace in the finale, preventing much time for viewers to speculate. One potential twist could be that Billy is the father of Claudia’s baby, while Alfie’s father might not be who he says he is.
Olympia, too, faces a tough decision: whether to protect Matty or confront Julian’s involvement in the Wellbrexa scandal. These questions, without clear answers, set the stage for what’s to come in season 2.
Olympia and the Dilemma of Julian’s Secret
There’s a brief moment in the finale where it seemed Julian might not be guilty of the Wellbrexa scandal. He had paid for his brownstone out of his trust fund, which initially made it seem like he wasn’t involved in any shady dealings.
However, Olympia eventually discovers that Julian did take part in the Wellbrexa study and stored it in a safe deposit box. The reasons behind his decision to keep it there instead of destroying it are unclear, but it’s clear he’s trying to protect himself.
Earlier in the episode, it was evident that Julian values his father’s approval above anything else. His emotional reaction to Olympia’s promotion and his father’s harsh criticism further reveals his complicated relationship with Senior.
Given that Olympia and Julian are still finding their way as co-parents, it’s hard to imagine her exposing him now. The truth will likely come to light eventually, but the journey to that revelation may take a circuitous route.
The Arrival of Alfie’s Father: A New Conflict for the Kingston Household
Throughout the season, Matty and Edwin had differing opinions on whether they should contact Alfie’s possible father. In the finale, however, Alfie takes matters into his own hands and seeks out his father.
Though it’s unclear whether the man claiming to be Alfie’s father is actually telling the truth, his appearance still has a major impact on the Kingston household. The introduction of Alfie’s father could lead to new conflicts in the series.
While Ellie’s death has been a key motivator for Matty throughout the season, the question of whether others were involved in her demise has been less explored. If Alfie’s father is indeed linked to Ellie, he would naturally become a prime suspect.
Season 2 may delve deeper into this relationship and how it affects Matty, especially with the disagreement between the heads of the household on whether to involve Alfie’s father.
Olympia’s New Position at Jacobson Moore: The Impact on Madeline’s Plans
At the beginning of Matlock’s season 1 finale, it’s revealed that Olympia has secured a partner position at Jacobson Moore, beating Julian in a highly competitive race.

Despite earlier doubts about her chances, Olympia’s achievements—winning a major brand and securing a murder case victory—proved that she earned the role. Even after standing up to Senior in front of the entire firm, she took on the position with the same grace that she displayed throughout the season.
However, Olympia’s position could complicate things for Madeline, especially since she’s keeping a major secret about her ex-husband. Matty, who cares about Olympia, may find herself torn between loyalty to her friend and confronting the truth about the Wellbrexa scandal.
Despite Olympia’s difficult position, her new role as partner could offer a distraction for Matty, giving her a chance to focus on her work instead of the troubling moral dilemmas she faces.
What the Season 1 Finale Means for Season 2
With Matty’s web of lies slowly unraveling, the possibility of her deception being uncovered holds major consequences for the future.
Sarah’s involvement in cases behind Olympia’s back has been motivated by Matty’s underhanded actions, such as taking the Autry case from her, knowing Sarah’s personal experience with dementia. While Matty’s goal may seem noble, the methods she’s used to achieve it have been far from ethical.
This dark truth will need to be addressed in season 2. Despite Kathy Bates’ performance making Matty a somewhat sympathetic character, the truth is that Matty hasn’t grown much this season. Olympia’s hurt over Matty’s actions is understandable, but Matty responds with even more manipulation and blackmail.
Whatever direction Matlock takes in its next season, it’s clear that the stakes have been raised, and someone—be it Matty, Julian, Olympia, or all of them—could face serious consequences by the end of the story.



